I want to start the process of my next tattoo. I would like to fix all of the old tattoos I have that I am not 100% happy with. Some of my tattoos can be saved with color and line work but I think some will have to be covered up.. and a couple are just not workable at all.. thats not to say all of my old tattoos are bad, I do like some of them!

Ok, on to the point of the thread. which of these two should I work on next and what should I have him do?

My problem with this phoenix is that the details all blend together, perhaps if it was colored in it would look better?

Or should I fix this one next, its so faded a cover up might be the best option?

so which one should I have worked on next and what would you have him do?