This has seriously got to be the most difficult question I’ve ever had to answer.
Normally, I would not put The Cure in the same zone as the other bands, but I like The Cure, so I wouldn’t vote them off. I’m not a Stones fan, but voting them off would be akin to blasphemy. I would have to say Pink Floyd, because I was just never that into them.
Now for this to TRULY be Classic Rock Survivor Island, you should substitute Aerosmith for The Cure, and substitute the Beatles for Pink Floyd. That would really make this difficult.